Jump to content
RESET Forums (homeservershow.com)

Port Multiplier / FIS Based Switching


Shonk
 Share

Recommended Posts

Im posting this incase anyone is considering going down the same road as me

I decided to buy a 4 Bay Esata Enclosure
Most around are Sata II

I found the Startech S3540BU33E £239.99 RRP
Sata III / USB 3.0 UASP
JMicron JMS567 USB 3.0 Bridge
JMicron JMB575 SATA III Port Muitiplier

In ESATA Mode the USB Bridge is bypassed so not a problem

I found what can only be described as the Startech's twin
DLSIM DLA614SUSJ3 its clearly made by the same company that
Startech are buying from and was only £79.99..

Now that it has arrived here's my view on it
which will also be valid for the startech version

All this is via ESATA no idea about USB Performance / Spindown ETC..

Hardware Bad Points

1) Led's far too bright
2) Power button needs to be a power switch
3) Clip on 70mm 3000 Rpm rear fan is noisy(HD7015S12L)(24.42CFM)
4) Drives slide home to sata port and flaps up if nudged

Hardware Good Points

1) Confirmed it comes with JMicron JMS567 + JMB575
2) Follows OS Spindown Plan (e.g. enclosure doesnt try spinning them down every few mins) (I Believe Startech Quote 5 or 10 min spindown with USB though)
3) If PC is powered off Enclosure detects this and powers hd's down and keeps them down until PC powers back on  
4)Enclosure is solid feeling should disipate heat ok


What i did to fix Bad Points

1) Covered led's with insulation tape to dim them (theyr behind front cover anyway)
2) Nothing
3) Removed Clip on 70mm fan and clip on Mechanism
plugs into pcb with same connector as xbox 360 controller rumble motors
Soldered spare connector to Dynamode 3 pin fan reduction cable + 1 extra Dynamode reduction cable
Mounted 80mm Coolermaster 2500rpm 22db Fan (- 900rpm for speed reducers so 1600rpm)
with 4 3mm x 80mm wide strips of 3M VHB, 4 other small pieces in corner contact points

This created a very good seal around the back far better than the old 70mm fan
it also covered the 70mm fan clip points

4) 3 layers of 3mm x 15mm 3M VHB on either side of the drive before sliding home (drives dont flap at all now)


Things you should be aware of about Port Multiplier / FIS Based Switching

1) Accessing a single drive gives full drive spec'd speed as expected
2) Having Sata II based drives in the mix seems to limit peak overall bandwidth to around 260 MB
3) Your drives are only as fast as the weakest link if saturating drives at the same time

Example 1
Drive 1 Capable of 205 MB/s Read
Drive 2 Capable of 125 MB/s Read
if you try reading them both at the same time (benchmark) you will get 125 MB/s from each drive

Example 2
Drive 1 Capable of 205 MB/s Read
Drive 2 Capable of 400+ MB/S Read (SSD)
if you try reading them both at the same time (benchmark) you will get 205 MB/s from each drive

If all drives are SATA III my Marvell 9230 seems capable of around 415-420 MB/s Per Port
If one of the drives are SATA II and all drives are saturating the link you only get 260 MB/s or so

 

 

Size Comparison

image.jpg

http://s5.postimg.org/ebohww6tz/image.jpg

 

Drive Detection

image.jpg

http://s5.postimg.org/fs00f19qv/image.jpg

 

Port Multiplier Chipset

image.jpg

http://s5.postimg.org/51cdtcw47/image.jpg

 

Closeup

image.jpg

http://s5.postimg.org/ox8d8wd5j/image.jpg

 

Drive Flap Fix

image.jpg

http://s5.postimg.org/qg3rdvjpz/image.jpg

 

Stock Rear 70mm Fan in clipon casing

image.jpg

http://s5.postimg.org/6zj1rcolz/image.jpg

 

80mm Fan Mod

(external cables was delib so i could add or remove fan reducers as needed)

image.jpg

http://s5.postimg.org/6f40onvdj/image.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 2 months later...

I have moved the rest of my 3tb drives (Sata III Drives) into the enclosure

in preparation for the 2 x 5TB Drives i have on order

 

anyway here's the effects of using port multipliers (fis based)

 

Green = One Drive being saturated

Red = Two Drives being saturated

Yellow = Three Drives being saturated

Blue = Four Drives being saturated

 

Remember the weakest link dictates the speed of all 4 drives

hence if you look at Red the start of the second drive is only capable of around 160 MB/S

then half way through the second drive moves to a faster part of the drive

 

Green = Drive Limited

Red = Drive Limited

Yellow = Sata Bus Limited

Blue = Sata Bus Limited

 

29_August_2015_01_41.jpg

Edited by Shonk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Umm must find a card that takes 8 port multipliers

 

Im totally out of expansion room now

 

Internal Headers

1 x 240GB SSD

2 x 6TB WD

2 x 5TB Toshiba

 

Marvell 9230

3 x 2TB Samsung M9T Internal

1 x 3TB Toshiba ESATA Port Multiplier

3 x 3TB Seagate ESATA Port Multiplier

 

USB

1 x 2TB Samsung M9T (Portable External)

1 x 500GB Hitachi (Portable External)

1 x 320GB Seagate (Portable External)

1 x 320GB Toshiba (Portable External)

1 x 320GB Samsung (Portable External)

1 x 320GB Samsung Internal

 

18 Drives..

 

Drive.jpg

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats a bit overkill for me

 

Im after a marvell 9230 2esata 2sata really with support for more than 7 drives

 

I know the chipset supports upto 20 drives

but i cant find one with support for more than 7 devices

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...