Jump to content
RESET Forums (homeservershow.com)

What's the current best 16- or 24-port switch?


dvn
 Share

Recommended Posts

Check out this article on switches that gets to the unmanaged/managed:

 

http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/lanwan/lanwan-basics/30840-smart-switch-how-to-part-1-what-a-managed-switch-can-do-for-your-small-network

 

They did a three-part series that looks in detail at the features that can be leveraged in a smart/managed switch.

 

The DLink that you linked to certainly has the right feature set at that price point....a purely unmanaged switch.

 

Here is another on NewEgg:

 

http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/lanwan/lanwan-basics/30840-smart-switch-how-to-part-1-what-a-managed-switch-can-do-for-your-small-network

 

This is a smart switch that can "monitor switch performance, configure ports, even set up port trunks, VLANs, and traffic prioritization. Alternatively, use SNMP-based software to manage your Smart Switch. Shipped ready for use straight out of the box, it delivers switching that’s easy to set up and use. NETGEAR ProSafe Smart Switches are ideal for adding basic management to your unmanaged networks and extending your managed networks." At another $139, if you need to be able to tweak those parameters, it seems to be worth it. If you don't need these features, then stick to the unmanaged and save teh extra cash.

 

Like anything else, what is the feature set that you need and what is the budget? If you are cool without the managed/smart features and are set at being at about $150, go for the DLink. If you need to do port trunking, VLAN, QOS, VOIP phones, etc., then you are talking about the $300 or so price point.

 

Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks, Jim. Hey, can you check that 2nd link in your post?

 

My budget? I'm basically looking for the best bang for the buck under $150.

 

At some point soon I'm going to make a serious effort to use pfSense as my router. Since I know little about networking, I figure this is a good way to learn. Plus I hear that it's a better than the typical router you buy in a big box store. So, if I put all this effort into my home network, the last thing I want is a switch does not handle heavier traffic well. Basically, I want the peace of mind that comes with knowing that when the Internet seems slow, it really is the Internet and not some weak link in my home network.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16833122082

 

Duh! At $150, go with gigabit unmanaged. If you are not using VLAN/QOS/SNMP stuff, don't pay for it. Here is an unmanaged Netgear: http://www.netgear.com/business/products/switches/unmanaged-desktop-switches/GS116.aspx

 

And a smart one:

http://www.netgear.com/business/products/switches/smart-switches/GS716T.aspx

 

Take a look at these and you'll see the differences. You can then compare price and features. I run a GS724ATC24 port and love the performance.

 

Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are we still liking this DLink 24-port switch? I'm looking to replace a green gigabit 8-port TRENDNet TEG-S80G.

 

A 16-port works just as well for me, if anyone has a suggestion for one of those.

 

And can someone give me a little detail on why I would want managed or unmanaged? What can you do specifically with managed? Couple examples?

 

Sure do, I have the 16 port version and Tim has the 24 port version. Very fast. Throughput went up about 8% over my older 8 port.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest no-control

Plus I hear that it's a better than the typical router you buy in a big box store.

 

uhhh....who told you that? A well optioned prosumer router can be on par with PFSense. My DIR-655 has all the upper end capabilities including remote management, DDNS, VLAN, QoS, Firewall, Virtual Server, url filtering, DMZ, Static Routing, WiFi traffic prioritization & a Guest Zone. And this is an end of life model! Newer models incorporate dual band, better heat management etc...

 

I've installed and briefly used many router software packages and while they are powerful and great for certain applications. I have yet to find a need in my home for one that an off the shelf router didn't do for less cash outlay and lower operating costs. Not to mention the learning curve.

 

Just my $.02 worth

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dual-band with regards to routers is irrelevant. A good AP will take care of that, no?

 

As to my reasons, I've never owned a router that I didn't suspect. Admittedly, that may be due to a lack of networking knowledge which working with pfSense should increase, no?

 

How many users in your home? I have anywhere from 4 to 10 devices connected at any one time. While I'm sure most routers are advertised as capable of handing this much traffic, I have to wonder. So I will check out pfSense. If it's a fail or proves too much for me to grasp, I'll hook my old Netgear back up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest no-control

Was just my opinion.....

 

Admittedly, that may be due to a lack of networking knowledge which working with pfSense should increase, no?

 

NO

 

 

How many users in your home?

 

4-6 users, 10-12 devices at any given time not including VMs. The router has nothing to do with internal traffic between devices just WAN/LAN. Your switch should be taking care of LAN communication. If you have 10 devices simultaneously demand loading your internet connection. I doubt the router is at issue for poor performance. Most likely its your ISP package. While there is performance to be gained by going with a high end router make sure its your router that is the bottleneck before investing time and money. If all you want to do is learn....use a VM

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Similar Content

    • Dave
      By Dave
      D-Link today announced the immediate availability of its newest EXO Series Router, the AC2600 MU-MIMO Wi-Fi Router (DIR-882). The AC2600 EXO router delivers premium performance for 4K HD streaming, gaming and multiple device usage. The new router is packed with a number of premium features and provides the perfect combination of performance and ease of use.
       
      The AC2600 EXO router features amazing dual-band speeds of up to 2,533 Mbps1, a high performance dual-core processor for powerful wired and wireless network speeds, and AC SmartBeam technology which tracks connected devices for enhanced Wi-Fi speed and range. The AC2600 EXO router also features USB 3.0 and 2.0 ports for establishing a private storage to stream videos, photos, music, and files throughout the home. In addition, the router includes the latest MU-MIMO (Multi-User Multiple Input Multiple Output) technology, which provides a high-bandwidth Wi-Fi signal to multiple devices at the same time.
       
      “The AC2600 EXO router is hands-down the fastest router in our lineup this year and is specifically designed for 4K streamers and gamers,” said Oscar Reyes, vice president of marketing, D-Link Systems, Inc. “This router offers users the ability to maintain the strongest Wi-Fi signal on multiple devices at one time – whether streaming, gaming, surfing the web, or working from home, this is the router to rely on.”
       
      The AC2600 EXO router supports up to four data streams to maximize connection speeds to multiple devices simultaneously. Users can play an online video game on one device, while streaming 4K HD videos to another device at the same time, all with less buffering and lag for an optimal user experience throughout a home. The AC2600 EXO router also supports the latest 160 MHz bandwidth, doubling the throughput on support devices to help ensure the fastest possible speeds and to optimize intense data transfer. The combination of these features makes the router ideal for 4K HD streaming and lag-free online gaming.
       
      More about the AC2600 EXO MU-MIMO Wi-Fi Router (DIR-882):
      ·         Dual Band Wi-Fi Performance – Up to 800 + 1733 Mbps in 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz
      ·         Powerful Dual-Core Processor – Boosts wireless and wired performance
      ·         MU-MIMO Ready – Delivers maximum speed for each device
      ·         4 x 4 Data Streams – Supports 4 data streams for increased throughput
      ·         80/160 MHz Support – Double bandwidth for intensive data transfer
      ·         USB 3.0/2.0 Port – Remotely stream stored music, movies, photos, and more
      ·         High Power Antenna – Wider coverage throughout a home
      ·         QoS – Prioritize network traffic for seamless streaming and gaming
      ·         DLNA Support – Compatible with DLNA supportive media players, game consoles and TVs
      ·         Advanced AC SmartBeam – Tracks connected devices for enhanced Wi-Fi speed and range
      ·         Gigabit WAN and LAN Ports – Maximizes performance of wired devices like gaming consoles and desktop computers for the ultimate gaming multi-media experience
       
      Availability and Pricing
      The AC2600 EXO MU-MIMO Wi-Fi Router (DIR-882) is available now for $149.99 through D-Link’s vast network of retail and e-tail partners. Detailed specifications are available online at D-Link’s website.
       
      On Amazon, $149.99
    • Dave
      By Dave
      Look what D-Link showed up with!  Covr
       

       
      $299 at Amazon - http://amzn.to/2eM74RT
       
      Covr Wi-Fi System Key Features Include:
      ●     MU-MIMO Technology: Efficiently handles large groups of concurrent users
      ●     11AC Wireless Speeds2:
      -       AC2600 Dual-Band MU-MIMO Wi-Fi Router (COVR-2600R) – 4x4 11ac with up to 1733Mbps on the 5GHz band and 800Mbps on 2.4GHz band for maximum throughput with less interference
      -       AC1300 Gigabit Wi-Fi Extender (COVR-1300E) – 2x2 11ac with up to 867Mbps on the 5GHz band and 400Mbps on the 2.4GHz band
      ●     Smart Roaming: Devices automatically connect to the router and range extender depending on which networking device provides the optimal Wi-Fi signal
      ●     More Coverage: Provides reliable Wi-Fi for up to 6,000 square feet of seamless coverage
      ●     QoS Engine: Traffic optimization improves gaming experience, ensuring game traffic is prioritized over other network traffic
      ●     Easy Setup: Router and Extender come pre-paired out of the box for simple setup
      ●     D-Link Wi-Fi App: The new D-Link Wi-Fi app provides quick and simple set up as well as device management
      ●     Backwards Compatible: Supports legacy devices and Wi-Fi standards (802.11n/g)
      ●     Three Year Limited Warranty: Includes a three year limited warranty and D-Link’s industry-leading customer service and support
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
      Here is the full press release.
       
×
×
  • Create New...