Jump to content
RESET Forums (homeservershow.com)

Internal USB or microSD


Notbugged
 Share

Recommended Posts

The USB is 2.0 so I assume the microSD is faster if I can find a good card?

 

BTW, those HP official microSD still commanding a lot of $$$ on EBay.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's no real advantage to using either if you're booting Linux and just stick "/boot" onto the media as it's rarely updated so write endurance won't matter and as it's only the boot files, it will make marginal difference to boot times if you're using an SSD or hard drive as the root filesystem - this is what I do. Tried both and no difference it boot speed.  I have noticed a higher reliability with using a USB drive over the MicroSD slot, but I think that has been resolved with a BIOS upgrade as the machine kept losing the MicroSD card slot on reboot... again not a major issue as I rarely need to reboot the box.

 

The reason the HP MicroSD cards are so expensive is that they only use something like half the available cells on the card so when writes are made they affect the smallest set of flash so the card has a higher endurance than standard MicroSD cards, but if you're using it for just "/boot" it doesn't matter as it's mostly reads until a new kernel needs installing.  I have a document on the HP MicroSD cards somewhere 🤔

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks, 

 

I intend to use it as a normal drive for the Linux install not just boot. 

 

In fact I'm running debian on a 16gb USB stick but since I may need a bit more space for indexing so I'm wondering whether to go usb again or utilise the microsd

 

One possible alternative is to use either one for / and the other one for /var

 

On some devices the microsd slot maybe connected to the USB bus so there is really no difference 

 

Thank! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 options;

Run the /boot on a microSD card,   and then run the OS on a SSD in the ODD port.   this allows you to run the 4x disks as ACHI and no performance loss on the OS drive.

 

Another option is to run the whole Linux instance off a USB-> SSD via a converter  (Something like this) ,    I do this currently on my n36l microserver.   so far so good.   This allows you to have the whole OS on a single drive, which can be picked up and placed anywhere.   There is a limitation of 20meg/s read/write as its USB2,   but honestly its never bothered me.

 

 

NOW, if you want to get tricky and run VMware as the underlying host, then have the OS's as guests (what I'm trying to do) but have the storage solely as a linux file share its difficult.       Either partition a USB->SSD drive and have it boot VMware, with a Data store partition and run the linux install there too.    Pass through the whole b120i controller (if you have a cpu that supports it)  to the linux OS, and run mdadm 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ssd on odd port sounds like a good idea

 

I have use USB disk so far and can reuse it just for /boot

 

Do I need a special mount to install the ssd at the odd bay? 

 

My gen8 come without odd I'm not sure if it even has a sata cable and power there 

 

Thanks! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...