Jump to content
RESET Forums (homeservershow.com)
Yogen8

Upgrade the CPU (E3-1265L)of a HP microserver Gen8

Recommended Posts

Yogen8

Hello everybody,

 

I bought a HP microserver Gen8 to learn ESX and to host some VM.

 

This is my initial configuration :

  • CPU G1610T Celeron
  • 12Go RAM
  • 1 microSD (ESX)
  • 4 HDD (data)
  • 1 SSD (vm)

 

Really great hardware but I wanted to upgrade it to have more core/thread (and more VM).

After read many and many post like this :

https://homeservershow.com/forums/topic/6596-hp-microserver-gen8-processor-faq/

(and many many other :P )

I bought a E3-1265L (v1 > the strange and cheaper version ^^) with a TDP at 45W and frequency lower than the v2 (processor base frequency = 2,40GHz instead of 2,50GHz) and my understanding was the difference between the original CPU (TDP = 35W) and the E3-1265L is enough small to avoid thermal problems.

BUT... (do you expect that ? :) )

After many test, I know I have a new heating system in my house...

Let me explain.

I made some test with mprime and I found these (relevant) results :

 

ORIGINAL CPU : CELERON G1610T

power consumption : arround 52 W

cooler : CPU fanless and optimal thermal setting in bios

Zone            |    T0   |   T+30' |  T+1H   |   T+2H  |   T+4H  |
===================================================================
CPU             |   40°C  |   40°C  |   40°C  |   40°C  |   40°C  |
RAM             |   35°C  |   44°C  |   44°C  |   43°C  |   42°C  |
VR P1 Zone      |   46°C  |   52°C  |   52°C  |   52°C  |   52°C  |
===================================================================

 

NEW CPU : E3-1265L (v1)

power consumption : arround 93 W

cooler : CPU fan (2 NF-4x10 Noctua added on the cpu heatsink) and maximum thermal setting in bios

Zone            |    T0   |   T+30' |  T+1H   |   T+2H  |   T+4H  |
===================================================================
CPU             |   40°C  |   53°C  |   54°C  |   55°C  |   54°C  |
RAM             |   35°C  |   47°C  |   49°C  |   55°C  |   52°C  |
VR P1 Zone      |   46°C  |   58°C  |   62°C  |   62°C  |   61°C  |
===================================================================

note 1 : with the E3-1265L, all test without cpu fan are aborded after some minute because the cpu was overheated (manually stop over 65°c)

note 2 : with the E3-1265L and "cpu cooled by Noctua", the microserver is less reactive (ie : iLo need more time to give web gui)

 

 

I have some questions :

 

1) Do you think my results are good ?

I received the CPU in a very bad package and without anti-static bag. Maybe it doesn't work fine ?

 

2) Do you know a test to confirm the good preformance of my CPU ?

I don't know how to benchmark my CPU with similar other configuration

 

3) Only 10W TDP between Celeron and E3-1265L and too large increase of temperature ? Have-you the same result ?

 

4) Have you some warning point to share with me ?

 

5) Today, should we continue to use the B120I instead of AHCI for SATA performance ?

 

Thank's by advance,

Edited by Yogen8
I'm french, not found all my language's errors

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
dikkiedirk

did clean cpu and heatsinkk and did you re-apply TIM properly?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yogen8
11 hours ago, dikkiedirk said:

did clean cpu and heatsinkk and did you re-apply TIM properly?

Thank's for your feedback.

 

Yes I tried two times with the 1265L (because I had the same doubt) and I used ARTIC MX-4.

No specific TIM cleaner used (only removed the old TIM) but no problem with the Celeron when I tried to remount it to compare result.

 

You think the thermal result is wrong for my 1265L ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • Henrik
      By Henrik
      Hi Community,
       
      First, my specs (briefly):
      MicroServer Gen10
      AMD Opteron X3216
      Win Server 2016
      [...]
       
      Problem:
      The Taskmanager shows only 1 CPU-core instead of 2.
      (ref. image 1)
       
      Solutions tried:
      checked msconfig...no CPU-Limit set checked, whether other users see the same amount of CPU-cores in task-manager (ref. image-link (internal) 2)  
      Anyone out there with an idea to solve this?
       
      Greets
      Henrik
       

    • Sug7
      By Sug7
      Hi Guys,
       
      New member here, some great info on this forum so hopefully a few of you have experience with the Intel E3-1260L CPU running in a HP Microserver Gen8? 
       
      I know for sure it will work as I’ve seen some good threads on here but can anyone tell me if the upgrade made a noticeable difference in the fan speeds and noise?  
       
      Im looking at putting two Gen8’s in a living room in place of an old N54L so cautious of too much noise..
       
    • adih2001
      By adih2001
      Hello! Recently I've been thinking to upgrade the CPU in my HP ProLiant ML10 v2. It currently has a Intel® Pentium® G3240 (I got the model of this server that comes with the Intel® Pentium® G3240) and according to the manual I should be able to upgrade the CPU to a Intel® Xeon® E3-1220v3. Is this true? Do I need to change / get anything else? Thanks.
    • korso
      By korso
      Dear HomeServerShow:
       
      I just upgraded my CPU from a 1610T to a 1220L. All is going well, but I noticed fan speed has increase from like 10-14% to 14%-18%. I am wondering if someone else who upgraded is seeing the same just to rule out that I applied thermal paste wrong, screwed up heatsink install or something like that. I was expecting more or less (or even lower) fan speed as this CPU has a TDP of 20W, and the 1610T had 35W.
       
      Thanks a lot!
       
       


×
×
  • Create New...