WD Livewire Powerline Adapters

When I was at CES 2012 I got an opportunity to attend the WD event at Caesars Palace.  During the event they had a drawing and as luck would have it, I won these WD powerline adapters.  Powerline adapters have never been my favorite and not long ago I went around the block with several brands such as the Linksys, Netgear, and TrendNet with almost no success.  They suffered from various issues from not connecting, to very poor performance, and many with very convoluted setups.  When I got these I was very curious as to whether or not these would work any better than what I had tried in the past.

The Package

P1020053

P1020054

P1020055

P1020057

P1020062

 

Software installation and Setup

The first issue I ran into was the software that came up after putting the disk in the drive.  It had some sort of an issues with display drivers and would not display the text in the buttons.  As you can see the writing on the button was blank forcing me to guess as to which button I was supposed to press and what it said.  Once I got past this ridiculous screen, things got much better as it went into more of a standard install.

Setup Screen

Capture

After the utility came up, it immediately found the second device.  It allowed me to rename it as well as enter in the password which by default is on the device itself.

Capture1

Capture3

 

Performance Testing

Same Room

I used a very crude but realistic method of testing to replicate what I could expect in terms of performance.  I did three things, viewed the utility for the connected bandwidth, file copy performance, and various videos for playback performance.

The first test was in the same room.  As you can see it hooked up at 190 Mbps.  Large file copy was about 5.85 MB/sec. 1080P video stuttered badly however a 4.4 Gig  720P MP4 played perfectly.

Capture5

Capture4

Same floor and opposite side of the house

Second test was on the same floor put at two furthest points in the house.  Utility stated a much lower connection speed and large file copy dropped to 4.19 MB/sec.  Video playback was about the same same and the 720P MP4 played just fine.

Capture8

Capture9

 

Furthest point in the house and the lower floor

The final check was to go at the extreme sides of the house from one end of the top floor to the opposite side of the lower floor.  The utility did not show much of a change however the file copy dropped again this time to 3.33 MB/sec.  Video playback of the MP4 was still smooth and seam to play without any stutter.

Capture11

Capture10

Conclusion

I am not sure whether or not to consider these a success.  I guess that depends on what you want to do with them.  They are the easiest and most robust units I have tested and worked where no others would.  Other than the silly initial screen where you can not read the text, their software worked extremely well and was very easy to use.  When connected, the connection was very consistent.  Since you can hook 4 devices to one adapter, they are well suited for an AV rack where you can stream your VOD, update your guide data, or update firmware on your AV devices.

On the negative side, the performance was not very good for HD video streaming.  If all you want is to connect to the internet or stream lower resolution content, these will work out very well since the signal is more consistent than wireless.  However if you are looking to stream Blu-Ray content, crawl in the attic and start running Cat 6 as these are not going to work for you.  They market these for streaming HD and I would say that is a bit of stretch.  If you consider HD to be 720P with low to mid bit rates than yes, but if your version of HD (as mine is) is 1080P with a 20+ Mbs bit rate than no, these will not stream HD.  Don’t get me wrong, these are best powerline adapter I have tested but you should know in advance what you are going to use them for.  To me the powerline adapter technology is still inconsistent and is very dependent on your house wiring.  There are newer more powerful units that may be worth trying but as far as these go, be clear on what your needs are before you shop.  If you need multiple devices on one adapter then there is value to these, but if you want blazing speed, look elsewhere.

You may also like...

6 Responses

  1. Jay says:

    I have tried powerline and even phone line back in the day but the best and easiest wired solution other than running Cat6 (I would say pros/cons outweigh running Cat6 for most people) would be MoCa. I have four NetGear MCAB1001 adapters. Hooked them up and never look back. 250Mbps…no interference with other devices on the line….no circuit issues…no dependency on state of the wiring…and a coax outlet in just about any room in most houses.

  2. pcdoc says:

    Very true assuming you have coax where you need it. Everything is always a trade off so you have to decide what is important. Thanks for the comment.

  3. Jay says:

    I've had Power line networking in my house for quite some time. I have the NETGEAR XAVB1004-100NAS Powerline AV Adapter Kit With Ethernet Switch Up to 200Mbps and two NETGEAR XAVB2001-100NAS Powerline AV 200 adapters and I believe I posted this somewhere in the forums. The problem has always been that my dmark is upstairs and my entertainment system is downstairs. While I don't have an internet TV, I do have a 360, my blu-ray player and my new Roku XS. I have yet to have any issues streaming files from my V1 server to any of these devices. The two lone adapters are in different areas of the house, another 360 and when my wife roams around with her non-wifi enabled laptop. The biggest file that I've streamed was an encoded 1080p to .mkv that was 8.5GB in size without any stuttering in the slightest. Netflix, Amazon and Hulu all were fine as well.

    • Ray says:

      Hi All,
      Jay as you I have the NETGEAR XAVB1004 and used it for streaming Blu-ray and DVD rips without any trouble at all. What I want ot say though to pcdoc is I have read your post on streaming 101 and I know you get and stream the dvd and blu-ray rips without making them into an MKV, I tried your rout and had lots of trouble streaming blu-ray and DVD structure to anything I own, Thats when I tryed MKV and now everything streams fine even over my 5ghz wireless network without a hickup.

      I dont claim to know everything but everything in MKV for me work great and yes you do have to install a spliter/code pack, I use shark007 and its been great and his support is awsome.

      just my 2 cents.

  4. jvk says:

    I have a NetGear power line (don't know the model but it claims speeds at 80 Mbps) that I use to connect some computing gear that I have running in a closet. It has worked great for about 6 months now. Just Friday, I dropped Time Warner Cable and picked up Dish Network. The Dish receiver (Model 722k) needs an internet connection and has power line technology built right into it. We plugged in the receiver to the wall and it connected to my existing power line network without a hiccup, pretty cool!

  5. Mark Albin says:

    Very good post thanks for sharing. I have not had much success these products either…..I dont think that I will be running out and purchasing this product either…good thing you won it 🙂